« Black Caucus Member Expresses "Strong Concerns" | Main | Bush Is Willing to Veto Bill 'To Weaken' NCLB »

Checker & Rick: Change NCLB's Goals

| 1 Comment

Chester E. Finn Jr. and Frederick M. Hess (aka Checker and Rick) keep saying that NCLB, as as its currently constructed, won't result in better schools. Their first point is always that the goal of universal proficiency needs to change.

The current goal is "noble but determinedly unrealistic," as Hess writes with Rosemary Kendrick in this Education Week commentary. In this piece for The Education Gadfly, Hess and Finn call the goal "noble yet naïve."

"The inevitable result is cynicism and frustration among educators and a 'compliance' mentality among state and local officials," they write.

The best course, they conclude in the Gadfly, is for the federal government to focus on specific tasks. Among them are setting "common standards" (aka "national standards") and "promot[ing] a clear understanding of what constitutes unacceptable school performance."

Just last week, President Bush restated his belief the NCLB's goal should remain. Secretary Spellings has defended the goal in recent speeches (see here and here). But Finn, Hess, and others are starting a drumbeat against it. Will they be able to change the debate in reauthorization?

You can hear Finn and Hess state their case at this event to promote their new book on NCLB.

1 Comment

I would contend: noble, naive, but necessary. Otherwise, what child(ren) are we going to allow to be left behind? Hopefully, none.

Comments are now closed for this post.

Advertisement

Recent Comments

  • Paul Hoss: I would contend: noble, naive, but necessary. Otherwise, what child(ren) read more

Archives

Technorati

Technorati search

» Blogs that link here