« Early Look at Duncan's NEA Speech | Main | Draft Guidance on Title I Waivers Is Out »

Arne and Co. Tackle Mayoral Control


From guest blogger Dakarai I. Aarons:

The National Journal has rounded up a veritable who's who among education policymakers to talk about the pros and cons of mayoral control of schools on its new education blog today, including Education Secretary Arne Duncan, who famously said he will have "failed as secretary" if more big cities don't have mayoral control by the end of his tenure.

Duncan kicks off the discussion, saying: "Mayoral control also clearly defines accountability. One person is in charge. ... For cities that need to take bold action to improve their schools, creating a clear line of accountability to one person is an important step in turning around the schools."

But he also says mayoral control may not be right everywhere, but an important tool to consider.

American Federation of Teachers president Randi Weingarten says mayoral control can and does work, but her seven years of experience with it in New York City (where the law expired last week because of inaction by the New York Senate) shows that transparency and accountability are key, including independent reviews of financial decisions and a formal place for parents to be heard.

Rep. John Kline, the newly-minted ranking Republican on the House committee that oversees education, also favors a measured approach:

"Mayoral control has certainly worked well in some large cities, and I applaud it. But in other areas, engaged school boards have been able to implement the right kinds of reforms to improve student achievement. There is no one-size-fits-all approach to education, whether you’re talking about governance or curriculum."

Check out more responses here from other top thinkers, including former NYC schools chancellor Harold Levy, AEI's Rick Hess, Fordham's Checker Finn and NSBA's Anne Bryant. The school boards group delivered a stern smackdown to the secretary after he promoted the virtues of mayoral control at their April conference.


The City of Detroit is currently contemplating handing the reigns of our school system over to the mayor. The problem is that he's already got so much on his plate it'll be difficult for him to take on additional responsibilities. How much should one government be responsible for managing?


In government, responsibility does not make one accountable- that is one of the privileges of ruling. Look at all the carnage that US Presidents have brought to foreign peoples: Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan are just the latest murderous boondoggles. Yet, no trial for Clinton, Bush or Obama.

How can anybody listen to that Duncan drivel? What he wants, if you examine the words a little more closely, is a dictatorship in schooling (who knows where else). Of course, he will always defend his totalitarian mindset by uttering the sacred word 'democracy' as proof of accountability. "Well, if you don't like the mayor's policies then vote him out". But voting has always served tyrannical interests.

Comments are now closed for this post.

Follow This Blog


Most Viewed on Education Week



Recent Comments