« School Closings and Teacher Salaries in New York City: There's Something For Everyone Here | Main | Geeked Out Monday Links »

Should State Tests Require Students to Advocate for Specific Education Policies?: NY's ELA Test on Teach for America

A Voice Cries Out reports that this year's high school ELA retest required students to complete the following task:

Today’s ’situation’ told students that they were in a leadership team who has been debating ‘whether leaders should have experience in their chosen fields.’ They were instructed to write ‘a position paper in which you argue that inexperienced people can provide leadership.

They weren’t even given a choice about which position to take.

They then had to listen to a speech by-you guessed it-Wendy Kopp, about why she started Teach For America. In the speech, Kopp talks about how her lack of experience served to her advantage when creating Teach For America. In the speech she explains that TFA teachers, “challenge the conventional wisdom” that schools are limited in what they can do to ‘overcome the challenges of poverty and the lack of student motivation and parental involvement that is perceived.”

This takes us back to the social justice debate, in which we discussed how schools should and shouldn't deal with contentious issues in the classroom.

So is this fair game for a state test? Those who have pointed out schools' trespasses on social and political issues are generally cool with TFA, but what if the prompt instead instructed students to argue that schools need more funds to be effective, or that unions have a positive impact on public education? I reckon that some ed wonk/wonkettes' heads would explode.

To me, the problem with this question is that it didn't offer a counter-position, nor did it allow students to choose a side to argue.

I agree. The problem is that they forced the students to take a specific side. If you're going to have them discuss a controversial topic, you need to give them room to choose their own side and make their own argument.

The real story is how did it get on the test in the first place? If Virginia can throw out a question because "too many" African-American boys got it right then there had to be some sort of foul play to get this question in the test. Where are the checks and balances? I guess they are in the testing company's pockets.

I'd argue that (part of) the problem is that they only provide information supporting one side.

There may be some educational value in learning to take information from both sides, and argue a particular side. Debating teams do this; so do lawyers.

But this test question seems to be asking students to listen to one side, and then reflect it back. I find that problematic.

We shouldn't be surprised when Teach For America, one of the top-5 employers of recent college graduates, makes its way into the national parlance. I doubt this will be the last mention of it in a "formal" setting. After all, Princeton ranked Wendy Kopp above Paul Volcker and Richard Feynman on their list of most influential alumni (why do I get the impression that A Voice Cries Out would not be so upset if it were the even-lower-ranked Ralph Nader whose position the students were required to take?).

I don't think we have enough context to determine whether it's problematic that they don't let the kids choose which side to take. As has been mentioned, this is common practice in debate, mock trial, and my high school English teacher's classroom. I wasn't happy that I had to defend Emma Bovary's adultery, but I didn't think it meant that my English teacher was actually supportive of harlotry.

For all we know, the grading of the test will be more consistent and/or timely if the graders are only afforded a rubric with one side of the argument presented. Whether it's grading efficacy or debate-practice mimickry, however, I think the one cause we can rule out is some sort of vast non-lunatic-left-fringe conspiracy. Sorry, A Voice Cries Out, I know "A Brave New World" is a more interesting read than "How to Write a Standardized Test", but these fantasies are far-fetched, to put it mildly.

Socrates, Let's not shoot the messenger - A Voice Cries Out simply made us aware of this test item.

I hear your point on scoring, but I'm with Rachel on this one - it would be more defensible if they were given info on both sides and that had to take one. Just imagine if the requirement was to defend Ralph Nader's position on something - lots of people would be upset. So all sides are happy, I think we need some general guidelines about how these issues are presented in classrooms and on state materials.

I think your proposal, eduwonkette, is reasonable. The messenger, on his or her own blog, however, was not. Repeatedly calling this "propaganda" as if we know the intent of the testing company is hardly unbiased messaging. AVCO's other writings on TFA only serve to demonstrate further the prejudice with which s/he reports.

Comments are now closed for this post.


Recent Comments

  • Socrates: I think your proposal, eduwonkette, is reasonable. The messenger, on read more
  • eduwonkette: Socrates, Let's not shoot the messenger - A Voice Cries read more
  • Socrates: We shouldn't be surprised when Teach For America, one of read more
  • Rachel: I'd argue that (part of) the problem is that they read more
  • J.M. Holland: The real story is how did it get on the read more




Technorati search

» Blogs that link here


8th grade retention
Fordham Foundation
The New Teacher Project
Tim Daly
absent teacher reserve
absent teacher reserve

accountability in Texas
accountability systems in education
achievement gap
achievement gap in New York City
acting white
AERA annual meetings
AERA conference
Alexander Russo
Algebra II
American Association of University Women
American Education Research Associatio
American Education Research Association
American Educational Research Journal
American Federation of Teachers
Andrew Ho
Art Siebens
Baltimore City Public Schools
Barack Obama
Bill Ayers
black-white achievement gap
books on educational research
boy crisis
brain-based education
Brian Jacob
bubble kids
Building on the Basics
Cambridge Education
carnival of education
Caroline Hoxby
Caroline Hoxby charter schools
cell phone plan
charter schools
Checker Finn
Chicago shooting
Chicago violence
Chris Cerf
class size
Coby Loup
college access
cool people you should know
credit recovery
curriculum narrowing
Dan Willingham
data driven
data-driven decision making
data-driven decision-making
David Cantor
Dean Millot
demographics of schoolchildren
Department of Assessment and Accountability
Department of Education budget
Diplomas Count
disadvantages of elite education
do schools matter
Doug Ready
Doug Staiger
dropout factories
dropout rate
education books
education policy
education policy thinktanks
educational equity
educational research
educational triage
effects of neighborhoods on education
effects of No Child Left Behind
effects of schools
effects of Teach for America
elite education
Everyday Antiracism
excessed teachers
exit exams
experienced teachers
Fordham and Ogbu
Fordham Foundation
Frederick Douglass High School
Gates Foundation
gender and education
gender and math
gender and science and mathematics
gifted and talented
gifted and talented admissions
gifted and talented program
gifted and talented programs in New York City
girls and math
good schools
graduate student union
graduation rate
graduation rates
guns in Chicago
health benefits for teachers
High Achievers
high school
high school dropouts
high school exit exams
high school graduates
high school graduation rate
high-stakes testing
high-stakes tests and science
higher ed
higher education
highly effective teachers
Houston Independent School District
how to choose a school
incentives in education
Institute for Education Sciences
is teaching a profession?
is the No Child Left Behind Act working
Jay Greene
Jim Liebman
Joel Klein
John Merrow
Jonah Rockoff
Kevin Carey
KIPP and boys
KIPP and gender
Lake Woebegon
Lars Lefgren
leaving teaching
Leonard Sax
Liam Julian

Marcus Winters
math achievement for girls
meaning of high school diploma
Mica Pollock
Michael Bloomberg
Michelle Rhee
Michelle Rhee teacher contract
Mike Bloomberg
Mike Klonsky
Mike Petrilli
narrowing the curriculum
National Center for Education Statistics Condition of Education
new teachers
New York City
New York City bonuses for principals
New York City budget
New York City budget cuts
New York City Budget cuts
New York City Department of Education
New York City Department of Education Truth Squad
New York City ELA and Math Results 2008
New York City gifted and talented
New York City Progress Report
New York City Quality Review
New York City school budget cuts
New York City school closing
New York City schools
New York City small schools
New York City social promotion
New York City teacher experiment
New York City teacher salaries
New York City teacher tenure
New York City Test scores 2008
New York City value-added
New York State ELA and Math 2008
New York State ELA and Math Results 2008
New York State ELA and Math Scores 2008
New York State ELA Exam
New York state ELA test
New York State Test scores
No Child Left Behind
No Child Left Behind Act
passing rates
picking a school
press office
principal bonuses
proficiency scores
push outs
qualitative educational research
qualitative research in education
quitting teaching
race and education
racial segregation in schools
Randall Reback
Randi Weingarten
Randy Reback
recovering credits in high school
Rick Hess
Robert Balfanz
Robert Pondiscio
Roland Fryer
Russ Whitehurst
Sarah Reckhow
school budget cuts in New York City
school choice
school effects
school integration
single sex education
small schools
small schools in New York City
social justice teaching
Sol Stern
Stefanie DeLuca
stereotype threat
talented and gifted
talking about race
talking about race in schools
Teach for America
teacher effectiveness
teacher effects
teacher quailty
teacher quality
teacher tenure
teachers and obesity
Teachers College
teachers versus doctors
teaching as career
teaching for social justice
teaching profession
test score inflation
test scores
test scores in New York City
testing and accountability
Texas accountability
The No Child Left Behind Act
The Persistence of Teacher-Induced Learning Gains
thinktanks in educational research
Thomas B. Fordham Foundation
Tom Kane
University of Iowa
Urban Institute study of Teach for America
Urban Institute Teach for America
value-added assessment
Wendy Kopp
women and graduate school science and engineering
women and science
women in math and science
Woodrow Wilson High School