Solutions That Come 'From Away'
Policymakers and leaders have determined what's wrong with our educational system and how to fix it. Either part of that equation could be fraught with errors. What is wrong with our schools? How do we improve them? We guess the underlying question is: can schools be improved by those in the system or does pressure and mandate need to come from outside?
There is growing field support for the Common Core standards as a reform movement, less so, for the assessments associated with them. At last, recognition has come that a connection exists between teacher and leader performance and that of students. Can student achievement be improved by better teacher and leader performance? There is much debate on the ground about how to do this and how it is going.
We have lower than desirable standing in the global market. It is probably true that our students are not graduating college and career ready. Too many of our students cannot compete in the math, science, and technology fields; they cannot read, write, create, or solve problems as well as they should. It has been determined by concerned policymakers that this is a result of our failure to teach the right things in the right way under the leadership of properly skilled leaders. There is some truth for us to own.
We haven't been proactive in assessing and responding to the shifts in knowledge and skills our students need. We haven't made major changes to our pre-service programs in colleges. We haven't retrained the teachers already in the field in any way that becomes successful or systemic. While we celebrated our many successes, we have allowed some to fall behind and some to fail. We have created such an insular and circular mode of thinking, that we, ourselves, cannot see the way to improve our systems. This myopia allowed the forces "from away" to take over. How much energy have we wasted in pushing back? Perhaps our greatest challenge now is to decide how much time goes to resistance and how much to moving forward, albeit following someone else's plan? We often create our own Catch-22's.
No matter the potential within the reform initiatives, they will fail to improve student achievement and teacher and leader performance unless we own them. Why? Because the solutions are "from away." The term 'from away', as it is used in Maine and parts of Canada, refers to a person who was not born there. The inference is, if you weren't born there and haven't remained there, "You can't understand why we do what we do. You cannot know who we are and how we live our lives, our mores, and our culture. Simply, you can't know us." Guided by this "Down East" wisdom, we must take hold of the mandates "from away" and make them meaningful in every one of our schools. So we propose three actions we must implement to regain control of our profession and lead.
Nothing trumps personal relationships when trying to communicate complex issues. It isn't just about getting our message out that is important. It is also about opening up, listening well, and inviting questions. Building those relationships is essential, time aside. All of us benefit from an informed public unless we have something to hide. We don't.
It is essential that our mental models change and that those of our communities do also. No longer can we be complicit in perpetuating the message "It was good enough for me and I turned out ok." The world is changing faster than it ever did, accelerated by the use of technology. There is no turning back.
Stay engaged with Ann and Jill on Twitter.