« Critiques of Arizona's Take on Research | Main | A Portrait of the Immigrant as a Young Man (or Woman) »

Immigrants Still Feel Welcome in Arlington, Va.


I've been reading so many stories lately in my morning newspaper, The Washington Post, about people who would like to stop the flow of immigrants—undocumented immigrants in particular— to their communities that I was surprised to see a front-page article in today's Post with this headline: "Immigrants Haven't Worn Out The Welcome Mat in Arlington."

The article tells how educators in Arlington, Va., have really tried to figure out how to best teach immigrant students English and academic content over the years, and how the public schools are doing well. The article also notes that Arlington County received a more gradual influx of immigrants than has occurred in some other counties near the nation's capital, such as Prince William and Loudoun, where some county leaders have tried to curb illegal immigration.

Here's an excerpt from the Post article featuring an Arlington County board member that is worth pondering:

"The attitude has always been: They're here. They're part of the community. Let's help them succeed," said Chris Zimmerman, a longtime County Board member. He said his children attended schools with classmates from dozens of countries. "They got something from those relationships that you can't teach in a curriculum or show in test scores," he said, "something that will benefit them their entire lives."

For an account of what happened in a community that seemed to have an opposite approach to immigration than that of Arlington, Va., read "English Language Learners Feel Effects of Battle Over Illegal Immigration" from the ELL Outlook newsletter, published by Course Crafters Inc., a company that sells materials to schools for ELLs.

The article tells about the repercussions in schools of the passage of an ordinance by the city of Farmers Branch, Texas, to make it illegal for landlords to rent to undocumented immigrants. The ordinance was struck down by the federal courts. But apparently some immigrants got the message they weren't welcome in that community. This school year, according to the article, enrollment of English-language learners in the Carrollton Farmers Branch Independent School District, in Texas, which has more than 26,000 students, dropped by 12 percent, or 824 students.


There was an article in the NYT about a community in NJ that also unwelcomed immigrants. The immigrants got the message, mainly Brazilians, packed up and left. As a result, the town went bust. Downtown stores closed as the overall local economy took a nosedive. Who says immigrants, even illegals, don't contribute to the community?

I certainly wouldn't want a child to go hungry or be denied medical attention in this country. But I favor prosecuting employers for hiring undocumented workers. If the jobs aren't available, perhaps the illegals will go home.

I have nothing against immigrants, but too many people have complied with the system and waited years to come here legally. By accommodating those who 'beat' the system, we are spitting in the faces of those who didn't.

Perhaps we need to adjust our immigration quotas ... and urge the Latin american countries to pay their people a living wage, create jobs, and care for their people.

Lets be realistic! Who will clean the office buildings, airports, bathrooms and streets if most are illegal immigrants? The average American does not want to work in those environments not to say the educate ones.

Who will help build your homes, office buildings, schools and other things??? Will you leave your nice comfortable office job to work in those conditions???? The average American does not want that….

Who will serve our food, cook our food and pick our food from the fields???? Will you or the average American do that??? No if the average American complains about conditions in the office how can they survive doing manual labor????

You get rid of the illegal immigrants and you will see how this country will collapse. This country was created by immigrants. The only real people who can say this is their country and it was taken away from them are the Native Americans…

We should look at the benefits of illegal immigration also not just the disadvantages.

Comments are now closed for this post.

Follow This Blog


Most Viewed on Education Week



Recent Comments

  • Charles: ELLs in our state ARE required to take State standardized read more
  • Melissa: Maybe I'm just becoming jaded, but this feels to me read more
  • Anonymous: Are you kidding me....UNO is an organizaion that literally destroys read more
  • Meg Baker: Are any schools using ACCESS scores for purposes other than read more
  • Dr. Mendoza: This is great news i must say. Hopefully this DREAM read more