« Welcome to the School Law Blog | Main | Major Ruling on No Child Left Behind Act »

May Students Confront Witnesses Against Them?

| 1 Comment

In this week's "Law & Courts" column in Education Week, I explored a couple of recent court rulings about what I thought was an interesting question: Do students have a due-process right to confront the witnesses against them in school disciplinary cases?

As I discussed in the column, two courts in New Mexico and Illinois answered "no." As it turns out, most courts that have confronted the issue (no pun intended) have also ruled against students, citing such things as the complexity such a right would add at the school disciplinary level, the potential effect on whether students would be willing to inform administrators of their peers' rule-breaking, and even the prospect of retaliation against student witnesses if they had to confront the accused.

The New Mexico Court of Appeals decision can be found here.

Unfortunately, for the Illinois case, the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois' opinion is not readily available on the Web. I will post it later if I can.

1 Comment

Schools are the one place that courts continue to rule against the rights of students, allowing school employees to be above the law. Schools in the United States are starting to be just like in communist countries, where the government owns your children in the public schools and children, nor parents have any rights.

So much for the US Constitution!

Comments are now closed for this post.

Follow This Blog


Most Viewed on Education Week



Recent Comments