« Friday Roundup: Equal Access Act, Desegregation, and Adequacy | Main | District Court Rules Against Connecticut on NCLB Suit »

O, Canada! Sniffer-Dog Searches in Schools Struck Down

| 1 Comment

The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled 6-3 that random searches by drug-sniffing dogs in schools violate students' right to privacy.

In Her Majesty the Queen v. A.M. , the nation's top court upheld two lower courts that had thrown out drug-possession charges of a student whose backpack had been searched after a police dog alerted to it and the police found marijuana and mushrooms. The principal of St. Patrick School in Sarnia, Ontario, had invited police to conduct the warrantless search. Students were kept in their classrooms while the dog sniffed their backpacks.

The majority on the Supreme Court held that the sniffer-dog search of the backpack violated Section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which says, "Everyone has the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure."

"Teenagers may have little expectation of privacy from the searching eyes and fingers of their parents, but they expect the contents of their backpacks not to be open to the random and speculative scrutiny of the police," said a plurality opinion by Justice William Ian Binnie.

The Globe and Mail newspaper reports here, CBC News reports here, and Bloomberg News reports here. (Thanks to How Appealing for the tip.)

A couple of years ago, my Education Week colleague Andrew Trotter reported that more U.S. school districts were using drug-detection dogs. A visit to a school in Oklahoma City showed that "campus searches typically cover parking lots, student lockers, and school common areas, such as the cafeteria. The dogs do not sniff students directly."

The U.S. Supreme Court has never ruled directly on the use of drug-searching dogs in schools.

1 Comment

My name is Cristina Dumitru a marketing agent.We analysed your blog and we are interested to enter in contact with you and purpose to become an accredited BLOGGER of Publicationwewb.com.
Publicationweb is an information portal made by the people,for the people.We offer to all and each of you the possibility to have a free and unique right of speech.We are the only Web portal on wich all the cities of Canada posses their own personalised homepage.We invited you to visit the www.publicationweb.com and find your city.
To note that is completely free service.
In the pleasure to count you among our "accredited bloggers",
Thank you!
[email protected]

Comments are now closed for this post.

Follow This Blog


Most Viewed on Education Week



Recent Comments