« Pennsylvania Special Education Underfunded, Study Says | Main | IDEA Stimulus Funding Retains Existing Language »

Vaccines Don't Cause Autism, Court Says


A special court that was hearing cases by parents who said vaccines caused their children's autism ruled against the families today.

The New York Times has a story here, as does the Associated Press (courtesy of USA Today) and The Washington Post.

The ruling comes as a blow to thousands of parents who were seeking compensation from the federal government's vaccine injury fund. The parents were arguing that the mercury-based vaccine preservative thimerosal, or the combination measles-mumps-rubella vaccine, prompted the onset of autism in their children. The federal government has set up a special "vaccine fund" that allows people who believe they have been injured by vaccines to seek restitution through the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, rather than sue vaccine makers and put them out of business.

One special master in this case, George Hastings, came out strongly against the witnesses gathered by the parents of Michelle Cedillo, a 14-year-old with autism. His decision is here (pdf), and I strongly recommend reading it for a thorough understanding of the information presented. From part of Hastings' conclusion:

After studying the extensive evidence in this case for many months, I am convinced that the reports and advice given to the Cedillos by Dr. Krigsman and some other physicians, advising the Cedillos that there is a causal connection between Michelle’s MMR vaccination and her chronic conditions, have been very wrong. Unfortunately, the Cedillos have been misled by physicians who are guilty, in my view, of gross medical misjudgment. Nevertheless, I can understand why the Cedillos found such reports and advice to be believable under the circumstances.

The decision came just a few days after a story in a British newspaper that says a researcher who claimed a link between autism and the MMR vaccine in a 1998 study falsified his data. Measles vaccination levels in Britain are now so low that incidents of the disease are on the rise there.

Despite those two major setbacks, those who believe vaccines are linked to autism have not changed their minds. This is just another example of the government failing their children, they say.

This debate is far from over.


The burden of proof in a case like this is very difficult to meet because of the almost infinite causal possibilites of a condition such as autism, especially since so little is known about it. I feel for the parents of these children.

I feel for the parents as well. My mother taught for several years at the Texas School For the Blind, and taught in a life skills classroom, where the kids are very severly disabled. She had multiple children in those classes over the year, that were brain damaged due to vaccine injury. Mother's told her their kid got their shots, suffered seizures, and were never the same. I believe these parents...no question. I think the issue is why? It may be that there is underlying predisposition in some children, and the vaccines are the catalyst. Who knows, BUT we need to get to the bottom of it!

Comments are now closed for this post.

Follow This Blog


Most Viewed on Education Week



Recent Comments

  • sdc teach: I agree with the previous post regarding the high cost read more
  • Jason: That alert is from 2001. Is there anything more recent read more
  • Vikki Mahaffy: I worked as a special education teacher for 18 years read more
  • paulina rickards: As it relates to this research I am in total read more
  • Anonymous: Fully fund the RTI process. We are providing special education read more