This Week in Education

Alexander Russo's inside scoop on education news.

Written by former Senate education staffer and journalist Alexander Russo, This Week in Education covers education news, policymakers, and trends with a distinctly political edge. (For archives prior to January 2007, please click here.)

« Colbert Can't Shake Klein On Paying Kids For Grades | Main | Richardson Slammed For Misrepresenting US Achievement »

How The NEA Ended Up So Opposed To Miller/McKeon

2006Rotherham_Andy2.JPG
I wrote on Monday that the CTA was coming out stronger against the Miller/McKeon draft than the NEA, which had -- until then -seemed tolerably pleased. And well they should have been. However, Andy (Eduwonk) Rotherham (pictured) wondered how I could ever have thought that the NEA was supportive of the Miller/McKeon draft. And you know he's always right. Well, a look back at the week behind shows that it wasn't at all clear to me (or anyone else) how things would turn out on Monday -- though perhaps it should have been. Read below to see how it all unfolded.

Here's how things unfolded, best as I can figure out:

For the first few days of last week everybody said that they hadn't read enough of the details to respond (see EdWeek story here).

Even on Friday, Andy's beloved David Hoff quoted NEA chief Reg Weaver as supporting key elements of the teacher quality proposal (which they later recanted).

A Wednesday September 5 letter from the NEA to the Committee included both lots of complaints and lots of praise for the draft (here), granted for only Title I. However, no one reported on this letter, which would have been key.

In the meantime, USA Today, the Washington Post, and the NYT editorial pages had all expressed concern that the Miller draft was giving too much away to the suburban-dominated union.

Only on Monday -- when Weaver's testimony was released (PDF here) and Miller and Weaver got into it was it -- fully clear that the NEA wanted both a softer AYP system (which they'd gotten) and softer teacher quality standards (which they hadn't), and that their California brethren were jumping in (as they have in the past) with both feet.

Comments

The NEA is a hostage unit holding state and local EA's prisoner to soccer mom mentality, anti american pro red programs dirty neocon anti school programs bush and his s--t vouchers and putsd admins in bed with tchers, iinda like giving wolves LSD and turning them loose in the henhouse.
Anti lib anti neocon anti red 100% Am teacher from ohio

Post a comment

Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please, no profanity or personal attacks. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.

Alexander Russo

Alexander Russo
E-mail me

    Contributors:
  • Fritz Edelstein
  • Regina Matthews
  • Cassie Walker
Free weekly email reminder

Free daily email reminder:

Delivered by FeedBurner

The opinions expressed in This Week in Education are strictly those of the author and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.
Advertisement
My site was nominated for Best Education Blog!
Powered by
Movable Type 3.34

EW Archive