This Week in Education

Alexander Russo's inside scoop on education news.

Written by former Senate education staffer and journalist Alexander Russo, This Week in Education covers education news, policymakers, and trends with a distinctly political edge. (For archives prior to January 2007, please click here.)

Main

October 16, 2007

Veto Threat Over NCLB Reauthorization

It seemed like it was coming, what with Spellings hinting at it last month and all the fun that's been had over the SCHIP veto. And this President has never lacked for confidence, warranted or not. So, yesterday, the President said he'd veto any effort to reauthorize NCLB without maintaining its main provisions (President Bush Discusses The Budget):

"We're teaching a child to read so they can pass a reading test....I believe in local control of schools. That's up to you to chart the path to excellence. But it's up to us to make sure your money is spent wisely...I believe this piece of legislation is important, and I believe it's hopeful, and I believe it's necessary to make sure we got a educated group of students who can compete in the global economy when they get older. Yes, sir."

October 12, 2007

Bush's No-Name Cabinet

cabinetQuiz.gif
Slate magazine recently ran this piece about how unknown most of Bush's cabinet are, even compared to other unknown cabinets (A Bush Cabinet quiz). Much of it is due to the fact that, so late into a second term, only the most desperate opportunists are clamoring to join the Administration. The other, according to the article, is that so much of Bush's domestic agenda (such as it is) came from Karl Rove, not the DPC (currently headed by Karl Zinsmeister) or the departments themselves.

October 9, 2007

Spellings Spills To National Journal

CarusoLisa.JPG
There's not much that's really new or interesting in too many education stories these days, but not so in National Journal's Q and A with Secretary Spellings from Friday (Improving on '99.9% Pure' $$). In an interview with reporter Lisa Caruso (pictured), Spellings mocks multiple measures as do-it-yourself school reform, says that more money for NCLB will only come with a new iteration of the law, walks back from earlier statements about preferring current law to the Miller proposal, declines to apologize for the infamous Ivory Soap remark, and explains the origin of her Bush nickname. That's good stuff. The only thing missing from Caruso's piece is an in-depth analysis of what Spellings was wearing. (The black pantsuit? The big broach?) Find a friend who has a subscription. Related post here.

President Announces New NCLB Strategery

From the White House NCLB event going on right about now:

"Secretary Spellings and I are so pleased to welcome you all to the Roosevelt Room. With us today are a group of concerned citizens from a variety of groups, here to discuss the No Child Left Behind Act. People around this table care deeply about making sure every child gets a good education. We're deeply concerned about school systems that don't focus on each individual. Some school systems are just moving kids through, and as a result, our education system is letting too many children down, too many families without hope.

"So we're going to strategize [see, he almost said it] and work together to make sure the No Child Left Behind Act is reauthorized and made stronger. And so I want to thank you all for coming. I love your passion. I appreciate the fact that you care deeply about the future of this country, and that you believe, like I believe, every child can learn and we have an obligation to teach every child how to read and write and add and subtract.

"So thank you for joining us. We'll see you all in the Rose Garden here in a minute."

White House NCLB Event Later Today

white-house-picture-2.jpg
I don't know who the attendees are yet, but the President and the EdSec are doing a White House event on NCLB today in the Roosevelt Room, followed by a Rose Garden statement by the Prez. Stay tuned. Could be fun. Feel free to email snarky comments or fashion tidbits if you're there. That's what BlackBerrys are for. (thisweekineducation at gmail dot com, or 312-286-9242)

October 5, 2007

George W. Bush Was "Mainstreamed," Says Conservative Columnist

bush%20runs.jpg
Everyone hates conservative columnist Ann Coulter right now (she recently joked that perhaps women shouldn't get to vote). But she did write something a little funnier in her new book: "“President George W. Bush is evidently the first mentally retarded person to get a Harvard M.B.A., graduate from the U.S. Air Force Flight School, be elected governor of Texas and then be elected President of the United States twice. I Guess that's what they call 'mainstreaming.'” Yikes.

October 4, 2007

Will Universal Preschool Get "S-CHIPed"?

Universal preschool is going to be education campaign issue Number One, says Richard Whitmire (Preschool) based on all the proposals out there. Many would agree with him. But the recent Presidential veto of the S-CHIP shows that it might not be so easy to get something done. President Bush vetoed the S-CHIP on the grounds that it doesn't focus on the poorest kids who already have preschool and creates a major new "entitlement" program. Of course, politics play a part and Bush will not be there in the future, but the struggle shows just how difficult it is to get new programs created even when little kids are involved.

October 2, 2007

SecState Rice Visits Harlem School

condi600.jpg
"The secretary and the veteran Democratic congressman made a bit of an odd couple in the school, also known as the Harriet Tubman School, which is in his district, just steps from his local office...But to hear her explain it, the success of schools is as much a part of national security as, say, negotiations with the Iraqi government." (From Capitol to Halls of the Nation’s Future NYT)

October 1, 2007

Where's Spellings?

xin_190303201530515193726.jpg
In China, of course -- not in time to help the women's World Cup team (they lost on Friday to Brazil) but rather to help out with that whole Special Olympics thing.

September 27, 2007

Plural Speech Gaffes For Bush

PH2007092602551.jpg
As if the President's mis-statement ("Childrens learn") yesterday wasn't enough, a draft of President Bush's speech to the U.N. General Assembly was posted online with phonetic spellings and other markings that weren't supposed to be seen by anyone outside the administration (Thanks to Bush, bloggers are hooked on phonics USA Today).

September 26, 2007

"Childrens Do Learn," Says President In Latest Education-Related "Bushism"

bushisms.jpg
The Washington Post would probably not have written about the Bush education event today in New York if Bush hadn't yet again mangled the English language. During the event, he reportedly said "Childrens do learn" -- a reworking of his famous 2002 Bushism "is our children learning?" ( No Child Left Behind Is Working). Via Eduwonk.

September 25, 2007

NAEP Scores Vs. Little Rock

070924_whisper.jpg
It's a tough call, I guess -- stay in town and spin the news about the latest NAEP scores that are out today, or go to Little Rock to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the beginning of school integration? Well, Spellings is staying in town, and Deputy Secretary of Education Ray Simon is going to Arkansas. Not that the EdSec doesn't like herself some travel, of course. Later this fall she's scheduled to go to Shanghai for a Special Olympics shindig.

September 18, 2007

No More "Federal Building Number 6"

prh_01_img0074.jpg
First they renamed National Airport in DC as Reagan National. Now the USDE administrative building in Washington has been renamed after President Lyndon Baines Johnson (yes, the same guy who got the Space Center named after him, too). Soon, you'll be hearing folks saying, "See you over at the LBJ Building." Or, "The meeting with the Secretary has been changed to 10 am at the LBJ Building." Read all about it here. Via the FritzWire.

September 17, 2007

Spellings Rocks Cleveland -- Gets Good Press

070924_whisper.jpg
There seems to be no end of the positive press that EdSec Spellings is able to muster, even now with her efforts to revamp NCLB seemingly in shambles. Here Washington Whispers -- which only last week reported that she was going to run for Governor in Texas -- mysteriously decides that a ho-hum trip to Cleveland is worthy of not only a mention but an illustration.

September 14, 2007

Neil Bush's School Scam: The "Other" USDE Scandal

neil%20bush.jpg
"An independent watchdog agency has asked the Department of Education to investigate why President Bush's younger brother, Neil, has received money earmarked for the president's signature education initiative to sell a curriculum program that has not been subjected to the rigorous evaluation it deserves," according too this story (Why is Bush's kid brother getting federal bucks?). "CREW says nearly $1 million has been spent on the systems in 16 school districts, mostly in Texas, where George W. Bush served as governor before his election in 2000, and Florida, where brother Jeb Bush is governor."

September 10, 2007

Spellings Playing For A Stalemate?

Read all the way to the end of this NPR piece (Hill Panel Ponders Future of NCLB) and you'll see first word I've heard of that Spellings is saying she'd rather have the current NCLB than the Miller draft. Saber-rattling? Maybe. But for those who are most worried about multiple measures and all the rest, it's going to be a serious consideration.

September 7, 2007

Can Spellings Stay Focused?

0905_4.jpg
A few weeks ago, word was that she was being sought to head the University of Houston (Spellings For President). Now the rumor is that she wants an even bigger Texas job (Governor Spellings?). Next week, who knows? None of it's likely to pan out, and -- fun as it is to speculate -- it doesn't help her do her job if everyone's focused on where she's going next.

September 6, 2007

Spellings Urged Early Rumsfeld Firing, Book Says

Way back at the beginning of 2006, EdSec Spellings was apparently called into the Oval Office to give counsel on what to do about former Defense Secretary Don Rumsfeld -- and she recommended his termination, according to this book excerpt sent in by a friend. Who knew? Not that it made much difference. He resigned the day after the November elections. But at least we know she voted the right way.

August 17, 2007

Still Spinning The News On His Way Out The Door

meet%20the%20press.jpg
Karl Rove is still pushing NCLB during his farewell tour, even though the stats he cites have been widely challenged and the political support for NCLB has shifted. “Rove said he believes history eventually will vindicate Bush. As one example of the reason, he cited improvements in reading and math scores since the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act — a piece of legislation that even leading Republicans now view as flawed."

Meanwhile, Yahoo News dredges up this overview of where other Texans from the early Bush years have gone (Departures diminish Texas flavor at White House). Who's next?

August 10, 2007

More Departures: McLane Out At USDE Press Office

Today is Katherine McLane's last day as Press Secretary for the EdSec, she says. Heading back to Austin to work for the Lance Armstrong Foundation is the given reason. Time to go may be the implicit one. Interim press secty will be Samara Yudof. Mclane was in the job just over a year, according to this press release. Want to know more? Check out her astrology reading from Capitol Weekly. Congrats, condolences to McLane and Yudof.

August 7, 2007

Spellings For President

spellings%20new.gif
...University of Houston president, that is. From an eagle-eyed reader I learn that the Houston Chronicle is trying to draft her into the search for a new head of the school (Margaret Spellings our nominee for UH chancellor-president). "The Chronicle's editorial board, which includes four UH alumni, thinks the best qualified potential candidate is a University of Houston graduate, as well as the highest ranking federal education official..." She is "well-respected by both Republicans and Democrats, public school officials and teacher union leaders. She understands the full spectrum of public education, from preschool to graduate study, and recently proposed the administration's Plan for Higher Education, which aims to improve accessibility and affordability of college education."

August 3, 2007

Spellings Off To UNESCO

UNESCO_Logo.gif
"The President intends to nominate Margaret Spellings, of Texas, to be a Representative of the United States to the 34th General Conference of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, for the duration of the conference." (Personnel Announcement)

July 28, 2007

The Two Margaret Spellings

On your left, you have US EdSec Margaret Spellings -- complete with pearls, flag in the background, and that cute smile with her tongue. On your right, you have the somewhat frumpier Simpsons version of the Secretary, who looks (like many Simpsons characters) a little transgendered. Sorry, Madame Secretary -- it was the best I could do.


July 24, 2007

EdSec Wants More "Pocket Protector" Skills

pocket%20protector.jpg
According to this press release, EdSec Spellings thinks employers wants more kids with "pocket protector" skills, which means (a) geeks, (b) people who know not to put inky pens in their pockets, (c) something having to do with pocket pool, or (d) all of the above.

Here's the quote: "Employers today need workers with 'pocket-protector' skills, creative problem-solvers with strong math and science backgrounds," said Secretary Spellings. "The more students we train to be entrepreneurs and creative problem solvers, the more jobs they'll create, and the greater ability they'll have to improve the quality of life for others."

July 20, 2007

Spellings & Rove, Sitting In A Tree? As If.

spellings%20pink.jpg
Thinking she was going to talk student lending or something, EdSec Spellings instead got some surprise questions about her former suitor, Karl Rove, from the Washington Post editorial board -- a conversation that eventually led to her tearing up (though not over Rove, thankfully (A Pop Quiz for the Education Secretary (Washington Post)).

July 18, 2007

Rod Paige, Beauty Contest Judge

Paige%2002-23-04.jpg
What to do if you're no longer the Education Secretary and can't judge schools anymore? Judge beauty contests, of course. In Mississippi. That's what Rod Paige is doing these days, according to this Sun Herald story (Miss Heritage is the new Miss Mississippi). Better to judge than be judged, I guess.

July 2, 2007

Aspen-Bound EdSec

aspen%20grove.JPG
Early summer in Aspen is not a bad place to be, so it's no surprise that the EdSec is going to be there this week, ostensibly for an Aspen Institute confab on the 5th and 6th -- one session on education, and the other on women in politics. Nice work if you can get it.

Briggs Nominated & Confirmed For USDE Post

KerriBriggs.jpg
I'm not sure why anyone would want to stay in the USDE so late in the game and when the chips are down as they are now, but I guess some people are loyal that way and a promotion doesn't hurt. Congrats, condolences, per usual.

Over-Reacting On Deseg Implications?

Maybe those legal affairs correspondents went a little overboard about the deseg case last week, says Jeff Rosen in the Sunday NY Times: Can a Law Change a Society?

June 29, 2007

Citizen's Commission On Supreme Court Decision: Deseg Not Outlawed

Here's an email from CCCR honcho Dianne Piche that highlights the idea that yesterday's decision doesn't make it illegal or impossible to promote school integration:

"All programs that consider race in order to foster diversity have NOT been outlawed. The votes were 5-4 against the Seattle and Louisville school districts AND 5-4 in favor of legal principles favoring diversity. This so-called “split court” is not unlike the famous “Bakke” decision in the late 1970s, where the Court struck down an affirmative action policy with respect to admissions to the University of California-Davis medical school, while at the same time setting forth legal principles enabling some forms of affirmative action to be preserved."

Read the full email below [a letter to Piche's grad students].

Continue reading "Citizen's Commission On Supreme Court Decision: Deseg Not Outlawed" »

June 27, 2007

Students Explain Torture Letter Delivered To President Bush

Watch three of the 50 Presidential Scholars who signed and delivered a letter to GWB during the Monday NCLB event:

Or, if you're more into text, read an explanation of what happened and why here.

June 26, 2007

Presidential Scholars Chide President On Human Rights

Forget NCLB. The new class of Presidential Scholars apparently decided to put a little heat on the President in his own house, according to The Cheese Sandwich blog (The Kids Are Alright), calling on him to end torture and illegal detentions, among other things.

NCLB Making AYP, Says President

While most of political Washington is up in arms about the VP declaring himself not a part of the executive branch, there are still education events on the calendar. As you can see, the President's remarks at this one (video here) include the standard fare (yay, NCLB reauthorization, yay TIF and STEM). Perhaps the most dramatic claim in the President's remarks was as follows: "During the most recent five-year period on record, nine-year-olds made more progress in reading than in the previous 28 years combined." That one's new to me, and a little hard to believe. Someone's going to have to fact-check that one. As far as shows of force go, this one seems pretty weak. McKeon and Castle are mentioned, but no Miller or Kennedy. Even the First Lady, recently enlisted to help with reauthorization, couldn't make it.

June 20, 2007

Charter School Smarick Wins White House Fellows Spot

AndySmarick.gif
Not to be outdone by Michelle Rhee's splashy entry into the public sector last week, charter advocate and political up-and-comer Andy Smarick has just been named one of the 15 White House Fellows for 2007-2008. Under the program, folks from outside the federal government apply to work in the White House for a year. And everyone knows that fellows run things in DC. Lots of future stars have participated. Not that Andy isn't already a star among charteristas. Most recently, he's been COO for the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools. Congrats, condolences, etc.

May 25, 2007

Growth Models For Everybody!

DSC_1786.jpg
Apparently in honor of Memorial Day Weekend, the USDE announced news on the growth model front for us all to consider with our hot dogs and diet Cokes. Basically, Iowa and Ohio get to join North Carolina and Tennessee in the growth model club, plus Florida. It's more flexibility for states, without caving in on what NCLB s supposed to be all about. How do I know? Because it says that they're going to follow the "bright-line principles of NCLB," and that sounds cool and reassuring. Like "benchmarks." Let the celebrations begin!

Continue reading "Growth Models For Everybody!" »

May 24, 2007

The Secretary's Necklace: Too Bad It Wasn't Larimar

spellings1.jpg
I am informed (not by the USDE) that Secretary Spellings was wearing a necklace made of rose quartz, not larimar, the other night on The Daily Show. "Reflecting the azure blue waters of the Caribbean, Larimar is a recently discovered rare gemstone found in only one minesite on our Planet,"according to this website. Too bad. According to the site, "Larimar works to bring truth to the communications process."

May 23, 2007

Spellings On The Daily Show: Watch It For Yourself

Forget what I have to say (below), and check out the video yourself:

That face she makes when asked about smiting the teachers unions is good, as is the wink she gives when offering her "I don't recall" answer.

Spellings Is To Gonzales As "I Don't Recall" Is To Lunchables

For anyone who's not an education geek, the real fun of last night's Daily Show wasn't EdSec Spellings' appearance but rather the show's hilarious coverage of the current immigration debate going on in Congress, which included one segment in which a correspondent says reform opponents are worried about the US becoming a "backup" country for illegal immigrants -- "like Wesleyan," and another correspondent, this one tall white and balding, goes to Mexico and try and get back into the US illegally with the help of his burro "Smuggly." Hilarious, over the top, can't-believe-they-said-that kind of stuff that's usually found on the Colbert Report, not The Daily Show.

lunchables.jpg
Then Spellings came on, wearing a light blue blouse and a matching double-strand necklace that was either aquamarine or larimar. Stewart took out some pencils and Lunchables, thanked Spellings for being on the show, and handed her an apple she later smoothly attempted to give back to him for some added nutrition (the Lunchables and CapriSun folks are pissed).

Asked about NCLB's alleged curriculum-narrowing, Spellings responded with the usual talking point ("kids need to read to learn social studies"). Asked whether she would want to smite the teachers unions on the head if she were Education God for a day, Spellings smirked and paused -- and then perhaps sensing that she was on the verge of pulling a Rod Paige -- said "kidding!" Asked about the student loan scandal, Spellings said it was complex or something like that and Stewart -- clearly knowing and caring little about the topic -- let it pass.

gonzalez%20senate.jpg
Perhaps the best moment came at the end, when Stewart asked Spellings an old school SAT analogies question (they don't do those anymore, Daily Show writers) that went something like: Alberto Gonzales is to "I don't recall" as trees are to....(d) "I don't recall," the answer Spellings chose. Indeed. [UPDATE: You can see video of this last bit here.]

Over all, it was a harmless exercise, neither particularly humorous nor scathing. Stewart treated Spellings with a combination of kid gloves and that mystified air that most folks display when talking about education (why is it so hard, what is the problem, etc.) Spellings did fine.

May 21, 2007

Spellings Lucky She's Not Going To Be On Colbert

070528_whisper.jpg
In honor of EdSec Spellings' appearance [tomorrow] tonight on The Daily Show (lucky for her she's not going to be on Colbert, who's much harder on his guests), here's the transcript from Stephen Colbert's famous spoof, No Guns Left Behind, about how the answer to school safety is to arm the teachers: here. Enjoy. She's also apparently an American Idol fanatic.

It seems a little frivolous, given her current circumstances. I mean, shouldn't she be hanging out close to home, fixing student loans and Reading First instead of indulging herself? But then again, Stewart will probably fall for the charm like everyone else does. That woman can do no wrong when it comes to charming the press.

May 18, 2007

Why Spellings (Probably) Won't Get Canned

Now that Wolfowitz is out at the World Bank, and Gonzalez seems poised for his own departure from Justice, it might seem logical that Spellings would be next. And, to some, her departure would be an appropriate result given the current spate of scandals plaguing the Education Department.

However, there are a number of reasons why Spellings won't get canned, for practical, political, and other reasons. For starters, the Democratic lust for blood is likely to be sated somewhat by the Wolfowitz and Gonzalez departures. Ditto for the media. No lawmaker has taken the lead on the Spellings issue -- out of fear of Kennedy and Miller or insufficient evidence of harm. Kennedy hasn't even scheduled a hearing.

Then there's the fact that the two main victim/accusers in the Reading First situation (Doherty and Slavin) are both somewhat unsympathetic characters. Doherty apparently lied about his wife's working for a DI company. Slavin has been a remarkably successful proponent of SFA for at least a decade.

Last but not least, the evidence is still thin and our tolerance is high. A revolving door between the USDE and the loan industry? Sure. Poor oversight of major programs? OK. But we're used to all that at this point, given Iraq and New Orleans. Financial gain for Bush friends? Yeah.

May 17, 2007

Maybe The RNC Email System Just Works Better?

The Gonzalez echoes continue today with the accusation that Education officials may have used unofficial email addresses to communicate about Reading First, just like it was said White House and Department of Justice officials might have done about firing those poor attorneys. In that case, officials were accused of using their Republican National Committee email addresses, in part to avoid having their communications stored on government computers or available to groups that wanted to FOIA the communication.

Maybe the RNC email system just works better? And what about personal preference? I mean, I like Gmail, but some folks like AOL or Earthlink.

Kame’enui KO'd: Reading First Official To Leave ED

kameenui.jpg
Embattled RF advisor Ed Kame'enui is leaving his federal post, according to this EdWeek story (Former ‘Reading First’ Adviser to Leave Federal Post). You may recall Kame'enui as one of the folks who testified in front of Cong. Miller a few weeks ago, and was one of four folks who were hung out to dry in the Kennedy report. However, accounts differ as to whether Kame’enui was fired, is resigning, or is just finishing out his contract.

UPDATE: Group Wants Probe of Education E-Mails
A private watchdog group asked the Education Department's inspector general on Wednesday to investigate the possible improper use of private e-mail accounts to conduct official department business.

May 16, 2007

Reading First Scandal Moves Up The Media Food Chain

brian%20ross%20blotter%20abc.jpg
ABC News' Brian Ross has been tracking the Reading First thing online for a while now at his website, The Blotter, but it wasn't until last night that the nightly broadcast jumped into the fray with a segment about how Reading First benefited a bush benefactor, Randy Best of Voyager, which sold for $360M. You can read about it and watch the segment online. It includes Slavin and Cindy Cupp, whose programs were excluded, and an interview with Cong. Miller. Over-simplified? Sure. Still not the lead story? Of course not. But it's another step up the media food chain for the scandal. Plus which, now we know that Slavin's brother works in broadcast news.

May 15, 2007

Hey, Let's Convene, Says Spellings To The Hill

In a letter from EdSec Spellings sent the day after she appeared in front of the House education committee, Spellings urges the committee leaders to...get back to work on NCLB?

"I acknowledge your committee’s oversight function. I look forward to answering your questions and those of other members, and to meeting with any members who would like to discuss these matters in further detail...I am hopeful that the pursuit of oversight will not delay moving forward legislatively on these two important laws."

Full text below.

Continue reading "Hey, Let's Convene, Says Spellings To The Hill" »

May 14, 2007

Awkward...And Off Message

spellingkennedy.jpg
Maybe this Kennedy-Spellings editorial was put into action long ago, but having it come out just now seems downright awkward. Spellings is just coming off her rough appearance in front of the House committee, and is presumably going to have do another round of the same in front of Kennedy. Not to mention that the topic -- dropout prevention -- seems wildly off message. What a 90s way to generate interest in school reform. It's all about STEM, now, baby! Those Gates folks must have put them up to it.

The NYT And Me

While others may insist on praising her performance for a little while longer, at least the NYT editorial page has joined the fray in pointing out that Spellings' "it's not my fault" excuse is neither satisfying nor particularly plausible.

May 11, 2007

From The Huffington Post: Spellings Pulls A Gonzalez

spellings%20black.jpg
My latest oeuvre from The Huffington Post: Is Education Secretary Spellings The Next Alberto Gonzales? "The only thing saving Education Secretary Margaret Spellings from drifting into Alberto Gonzales territory right now is, well, Alberto Gonzales." As always, please let me know if I've missed anything or gotten it entirely wrong.

Continue reading "From The Huffington Post: Spellings Pulls A Gonzalez" »

May 7, 2007

Greeding First: What About Beth Ann Bryan?

A few DC insiders have written me saying that Sec. Spellings conspicuously left one name off the list when she basically hung out to dry all of those who were "responsible" for the Reading First fiasco at last week's EWA meeting: Beth Ann Bryan. Bryan, currently a lobbyist with Akin Gump, was a senior advisor to Paige and, according to some, was Spellings' plant in the Department and the contact person for Susan Neuman.

bryan%20and%20kress.jpg
Here she is, pictured with Sandy Kress right after the passage of NCLB. Maybe this is just more Austin-Houston feuding (talk about the Hatfields and the McCoys). Bryan came into the Administration in early 2001 after having served as GW Bush's education policy advisor in Texas. Her current client list according to OpenSecrets is here. She's apparently on Miller's list already, but I hadn't seen her name in the press. Comment or email me if you know more, one way or the other, or have other information.

May 4, 2007

Redacted Reading First Emails

redacted.jpg
I'm told by a knowledgeable insider that FOIA'd versions of at least some of these documents requested by one or more journalists came back heavily redacted (blacked out). I've gotta learn how to do that FOIA thing one of these days.

Will Admin. Claim Executive Privilege Over Reading First Docs?

spellings%20bush.jpg
One thing I neglected to mention about last night's Spellings appearance in LA and her comments about not having been intimately involved in Reading First is that, in response to a question from USA Today's Greg Toppo, Spellings said she wasn't sure whether the administration would release all the documents and emails that Congressman Miller had requested, based on executive privilege. Toppo pressed her on whether she would want to release the documents, but she said it was up to the White House.

Spellings Denies Early Involvement In Reading First

DSCN0386.JPG
In what may be a preview of her testimony at next week's House education committee hearing, EdSec Spellings explained at the EWA conference on Thursday that she should not be held responsible for the problems facing Reading First. She told the audience that as head of the White House DPC she was responsible for overseeing too many programs to have been so closely involved as Doherty and others have alleged.

"It would have been impossible for me to have been intimately involved with oversight of all those programs," she said, though she was "generally aware" of the status of the state plans. She said she met Doherty only after she became Secretary, adopted all of the recommendations of the OIG report, and that none of those responsible for oversight (she named Doherty, Neuman, Hickock, and Paige) are still at the Department.

At least she's not claiming to not remember. "I'm looking forward to it," she said about the upcoming hearing. "We've got a great story to tell."

May 2, 2007

Ed Next Profiles Spellings

Sensing a timely opportunity, Ed Next is rushing out its summer profile of EdSec Spellings to coincide with all the hullabaloo surrounding her upcoming appearance on the Hill, etc. Still, can a profile put out by folks (Finn, Petrilli et al) who are distinctly on the outs with Spellings be taken seriously -- and does the profile offer anything that we don't already know? Not from the press release, it seems. The fact that Spellings is on the hotseat is pretty clear, and we already know that Spellings was a hard-ass during the first few years, and then turned softie when she became Secretary in 2005. (I wrote about this nearly a year ago in the National Review Online.) But I'm sure former EdWeeker Michelle Davis has lots of new tidbits and information that will deepen and update the story, and, in fairness, the folks at EdNext have never done any ideological meddling in the articles I've written for them. Check it out and let me know.

April 23, 2007

Reading First Quotes: Criminal Or Civil Investigation?

While it remains unclear whether the referrals to the Justice Department are going to be criminal or civil -- or result in any charges -- everyone's got a good quote or two in their Reading First coverage:

House Panel Grills Witnesses On Reading First EdWeek
In an interview after the hearing, Mr. Miller said: “This hearing made it pretty clear that there was a very incestuous relationship among a small group of people in the Education Department and among contractors. They were very clearly using this program … for profit.

Reading program to get Justice review USA Today
It wasn't immediately clear on Friday who the subject of the investigation might be, or whether John Higgins, who led the Education Department's investigation, asked Justice to pursue criminal charges or a civil complaint.But Rep. George Miller, D-Calif., who chairs the House Education and Labor Committee and is investigating the program on his own, told Higgins: "I think when we put the evidence together we may join you in those criminal referrals."

reading%20first%20witnesses.jpg
Justice Dept. Is Asked to Investigate Reading Plan NYT
The civil division of the Justice Department is looking into his findings, but has not decided whether to begin an investigation, a spokesman said....“Reading First was and probably will remain the highlight of my professional career,” Mr. Doherty said.

Key Initiative Of 'No Child' Under Federal Investigation Wash Post
Education Secretary Margaret Spellings, who declined to comment yesterday, has said management problems with Reading First "reflect individual mistakes." But Doherty said nearly every aspect of the program was carefully monitored by the department and the White House, where Spelling was Bush's top education adviser."This program was always firmly under the watch and control of the highest levels of the government," Doherty said.

April 21, 2007

Reading First Heats Up: Criminal Investigation, DI Wife

I guess I dozed off a little too early during Friday's Reading First hearings, since this Washington Post story suggests that things have heated up -- a lot.

reading_doherty.jpg
Some of the best nuggets include: (1) Justice Department officials are conducting their own interviews, (2) former RF head Chris Doherty repeatedly failed to disclose that wife has been a paid consultant for Direct Instruction (now that's a power couple), (3) Voyager, one of the favored programs is a company owned by Randy Best (a big Bush financial supporter), (4) Reid Lyon now says things seem much worse than he "was told," and (5) Doherty continues to insist that the program was closely managed from the start (ie, by Spellings).

It's still hard to imagine this story breaking through to the political or massive media coverage level, given everything else that's going on. But the comparisons to Gonzalez-gate continue to emerge, and the Post story did make it to the Huffington Post.

Spellings Talks Safety On Sunday

meet%20the%20press.jpg
According to her press schedule (see below), EdSec Spellings is going to be on Sunday's "Meet The Press" (NBC) to talk about school safety issues.I wonder if they'll get in some questions about student lending, Reading First, or this whole NCLB thing. Do you think she's worried about coming in 2nd, like she did (to Squiggy Lenny) on "Jeopardy" last summer?

Continue reading "Spellings Talks Safety On Sunday" »

April 13, 2007

Why Student Aid Is Bigger Than Reading First

HC-GJ837_Stroup_20070412183646.gif
"At least eight top officials in the Education Department during the Bush administration either came from student-loan or related organizations or have taken lucrative jobs in that arena since leaving the agency," according to this WSJ story focusing on Sally Stroup and others (Did Revolving Door Lead To Student Loan Mess?). "Former Education Department staffers say a revolving door between the department and industry has led to lax oversight of federal financial aid."

By and large, this story seems to be getting tons more attention and a faster response than the Reading First story has gotten -- I'm guessing because its locus is financial rather than ideological, because it involves more than a couple of folks in the USDE, and because it involves banks and other lenders rather than states and districts and reading experts most folks have never heard of. Or maybe there are other factors.

April 9, 2007

Where's Maggie? Prepping For Reading First

Last week, embattled US Attorney Alberto Gonzalez had to cut his vacation short to prepare for upcoming hearings on the firings of the state attorneys (Gonzales Prepares to Fight for His Job). Maybe that's what the EdSec is up to this week -- during which she has no public appearances scheduled -- in preparation for the April 20th Reading First extravaganza on the Hill. At least, that's my theory.

April 6, 2007

Think Vouchers Are Dead? Think Again -- Again.

Vouchers2.gif
It's not that I'm particularly enamored or dismissive of voucher proposals. It's just that I think some folks have blinders on about their viability in the current political and policy environment. And, if the Bush Administration is willing to make controversial recess appointments this early in the game (as it did this week), what won't they go for?

"The recent adoption of multiple voucher programs at the state level suggests that demands for increased private school choice have not waned," according to this missive from the National Center on Privatization In Education at Columbia's Teacher College, which lists recent voucher victories and defeats in the states and predicts a Congressional showdown (click below).

Previous Posts:
Vouchers and Charterization Not Off The Table... Yet.
Vouchers & Charterization Proposals Not Necessarily "DOA"

Continue reading "Think Vouchers Are Dead? Think Again -- Again." »

April 2, 2007

Where's Maggie?

Monday, April 2
1:00 p.m. MST Secretary Spellings will travel to Mesa Arts Academy, a charter school operated by the Boys and Girls Clubs of the East Valley in Mesa, Arizona.

Tuesday, April 3
9:30 a.m. MST Secretary Spellings will participate in a roundtable discussion with Arizona business leaders, hosted by the Arizona Business and Education Coalition at the University Club in Phoenix, Arizona.

Thursday, April 5
11:30 a.m.CDT Secretary Spellings will attend an event at the Burnsville Chamber of Commerce where she will meet with Representative John Kline (R-MN) and Minneapolis business leaders to discuss the President’s proposals for the reauthorization of No Child Left Behind this year.

1:00 p.m. CDT Secretary Spellings will travel to Grainwood Elementary School in Prior Lake, Minnesota, to visit classrooms and participate in an assembly with students and faculty. Secretary Spellings will discuss President Bush’s proposals for reauthorization of No Child Left Behind this year.

March 23, 2007

Where's Maggie?

I'm not entirely sure what to make of it, but I'm hearing that EdSec Spellings' agenda for this morning includes not only her public appearance and speech at a big teachers conference in NYC but also a private meeting on technology, ed tech, and competitiveness issues, which haven't really been her strong suit. If you're there, and bored, snap a pic of the proceedings on your cameraphone or send us a text message at thisweekineducation@gmail.com

Sex Predator Scare Tactics

gonzaleskids.jpg
It's not just newspapers and TV news that like to use scare tactics to scare and distract us with stories about kids and sex and drugs. According to this from the Huffington Post, embattled AG Al Gonzalez is going to "talk with local media in dozens of cities Friday about keeping kids safe from sexual predators." Conveniently, this means getting out of DC (Gonzales PR Strategy).

March 21, 2007

Former USDE Deputy Sec. Turns Self In, Pays Up

hickock.jpgEarly on in the Bush administration, former USDE official Eugene (Wild Bill) Hickok was one of the point men on NCLB enforcement -- talking tough during the Paige era and making states do all sorts of horrible things. Last I remember, Hickok had moved into the private sector and was being given what some thought was too much space in the Washington Post to talk about the importance of tutoring (see here for all about that).

His outlaw ancestry rearing up, Hickok's now back in the news, having just settled with the US Government over having not sold 800 shares of BofA stock before joining the government. They're a lender, he was supposed to get rid of them along with other stocks he did sell. In a statement Hickok writes that he didn't know what was going on until he was about to leave the government. He says he turned himself in and wasn't trying to evade the law. (No news on whether this is indeed more fallout from the Spellings-Paige feud.) Click below to read the statement and see some links.

Continue reading "Former USDE Deputy Sec. Turns Self In, Pays Up" »

March 15, 2007

Reading First Defenders, Unite

Over at Ednews.org, Jimmy Kilpatrick has collected a bunch of Responses to NYT Reading First article, most of them defending the program or questioning DJ Schemo's reporting, including from Reid Lyon, Bob Sweet, Tim Shanahan, and others. The gist of what they're saying isn't much of a surprise -- they're trying to salvage the program -- but some of the details in the letters to the Times are quite interesting.

However, there's a new DJ Schemo article in the Times out this morning that describes Congressional criticism of the program, a Spellings mea culpa of sorts, and the much-anticipated testimony of Bob Slavin, who seems to represent the wronged party (not districts or schools, for some reason): Oversight Is Set for Beleaguered US Reading Program. It's not quite an Alberto Gonzalez-level mess, but it's a mess. Can't someone find a better example than Madison, though?

March 8, 2007

USDE's Kerri Briggs Moves Up -- Again

Briggs is moving up -- again (President Bush Announces Intent to Nominate Kerri L. Briggs as Assistant Secretary of Education). As per usual, congrats, condolences.

February 21, 2007

Lessons From Reading First: No One Cares About Local Control Anymore

Fresh off of his appearance in Hot For Education last week, former Reading First czar Chris Doherty is back in the news. EdWeek (E-Mails Reveal Federal Reach Over Reading) focuses on the extent of the intrusiveness in RF and the historic ban on federal meddling in local decisions. Lyon.jpgThe Title I Monitor details his close relationship with reading guru Reid Lyon, who is interviewed in the piece about his role and what happened ("Reading Czar" Served as Conduit Between ED, White House).

What jumps out at me when I try and figure out why these Reading First stories never make it to the national level -- I'm talking Good Morning America here -- is that the notion of protecting local control over education decisions is pretty much dead. Sure, as the EdWeek story points out, there's long been a federal ban on meddling with curriculum. And I'm not saying that RF and Doherty were right. But after Goals 2000 and NCLB and all the rest, local control is mostly a fig leaf in the minds of most non-educators at this point, isn't it?

If that's the case, as it may be, then the only thing I can think of that would make RF a national story is perhaps a love triangle between Doherty, Lyon, and former deputy Sandi Jacobs (now at NCTQ). Or maybe I'm wrong and it will keep bubbling up.

February 15, 2007

What If The USDE Required Security Checks For Teachers?

The security clearance issue keeps bubbling along, with a website with background and information (Employee Clearance - Home), which includes the letter signed and sent to the USDE (but no names of signatories).

There's big money in these USDE contracts and the regional education labs, points out Andy Zucker, the informal head of the rebellion, which may explain why so few folks like SRI or AIR protested publicly.

Remember, these are full-on security clearances, not background checks or fingerprinting we're all used to for better or worse. Previous post: Security Checks For Ed Researchers

February 13, 2007

Just How Right Wing Is USDE Nominee Bill Evers?

bill%20evers.jpgPlenty, according to Mike Klonsky's Small Talk Blog (Straight from Iraq to the DOE).

Evers has been nominated to the USDE, as described here.

Klonsky points out that Evers is from Hoover, was part of Paul Bremer's Provisional Authority in Iraq, and is an enemy of "social justice."

February 9, 2007

Mesecar (& Others) On The Move

mesecar.jpgAfter two years heading Edison's DC outpost, Doug Mesecar is headed back to the USDE for more punishment. Previously, he was Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy. He's going to be Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary in the Office of Policy, Planning and Evaluation to work for recent nominee Bill Evers. (Eduwonk on Evers here: It's Official, It's Evers.)

In other Edison news, current deputy New York City schools chancellor and former Edison president Chris Serf is coming under fire in the Times: Schools Official Deflects Query About Stocks NYT

Meanwhile, the FritzWire reports that Bob Stonehill who managed 21st Century Communities Schools will be retiring from the Department next month and is heading to Learning Points. Fritz calls him "Another difficult person to replace given his experience and historical knowledge."

February 8, 2007

Keeping Talent At The USDE

"Out of thirty-six federal agencies surveyed, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) ranked dead last on job satisfaction," according to this article in Slate (Department of Homeland Dissatisfaction). DHS also ranked "dead last on being "results-oriented"; second to last on "leadership and knowledge management"; and among the bottom five on "talent management." No word on where the USDE ranked, but I'm eager to find out.

February 7, 2007

"Scoundrels" At The USDE?

Eric_Andell.jpgThanks to a friendly reader for passing along this list of Bush administration "scoundrels", which includes an Eric Andell from the USDE who apparently did something wrong related to Safe and Drug Free Schools. Read all about it.

February 2, 2007

Labor Budget Leaked -- Where's Education's?

Highlights of the Labor section of the budget request have already been leaked (Al Kamen - Aide at Labor Found Budget's Weaknesses, So Democrats Don't Have To - washingtonpost.com) -- where's education's? I'm counting on one of you folks who've already been briefed to pass something along. You know who you are.

January 30, 2007

Clowns To The Left Of Her, Jokers To The Right

EdSec Spellings is between more than a couple rocks and hard places these days. While lots of folks on the Hill are ramping up to see if the Administration proposes "enough" of a funding increase for NCLB in the budget, another set of folks are pushing at the EdSec to enforce the public school transfer provision in the current law, which has been blocked, sidestepped, and generally ignored for the last five years. To wit: "Leaders of 25 state and national policy organizations sent their request through a letter to Spellings on Friday."

Everyone's failure to implement the public school choice provision (and its structural weaknesses) have only served to create support for a stronger transfer provision that could include private schools. That's exactly what the President outlined in the SOTU.

January 29, 2007

When The EdSec Meets The Blob

So apparently the EdSec is actually showing up at the NSBA event in DC today -- I wonder if she knows (or cares) what they're saying about her precious little NCLB on their blogsite. According to BoardBuzz, American schools are not in crisis, AYP just needs some...softening, and hey, Maggie, send cash. As for any new elements or requirements? Not so much.

"We cannot improve the law just by piling more layers onto it," opines the Buzz. "Instead, we must focus on improving NCLB’s accountability framework first and foremost. Get that part (and of course, the funding) right, and then think about any possible additions."

The rest of the week, the EdSec is in GA for some school and group events, back in DC for the National Prayer Breakfast, and then in NC at the Annual Emerging Issues Forum at the McKimmon Center for Extension & Continuing Education at North Carolina State University on higher ed. Last but not least, Friday with "Hispanic leaders" on NCLB.

January 25, 2007

Adminstration Pushes Its NCLB Plan -- "Kit And Kaboodle"

Slowly, the most important details of the Bush reauthorization plan are coming out -- a private school option we've seen before (but will play differently now that Congress is on record for vouchers in DC and New Orleans), the likely expansion of the growth model option for meeting AYP, some uncertain language regarding highly qualified teachers, and -- most obviously inflammatory -- beefed-up requirements for schools in restructuring and districts with inequitable distribution of teachers that could abrogate collective bargaining agreements and contradict state or local charter law.

The reactions so far have been as you'd expect. But the main thing missing or underplayed from the NCLB reauthorization coverage so far is that, in essentially rolling out their reauthorization proposal this week, the Administration made a choice that has substantive and political ramifications.

They could have waited until the Aspen Commission report came out. They could have developed a joint proposal with Kennedy and Miller. They could have waited until the budget was released next week. But they didn't. Of course, this approach let's the Administration do what it did for many months on Iraq, which is to say "we have a plan, where's yours?" And that's worked out really well for them so far, I guess.

January 24, 2007

Reaction Roundup -- What Did You Think Of The Speech?

I'm still groggy from trying to give immediate reactions to the President's speech last night (Live-Blogging The State Of The Union) -- which was fun but ridiculous -- meanwhile, others make some interesting (and similar) points this morning:

UPDATE: A Constrained Vision: "At the State of the Union speech tonight, two of the First Lady's guests had something to do with education." (Ed policy in the First Lady's box)

UPDATE 2: Get Schooled: "It didn't take President Bush long to bring up education in his "State of the Union" address last night, and it took even less time for him to move on to other topics." ('No Child' Goes On)

UPDATE 3: Chairman Miller: "The task of renewing the law will be made much more difficult if the President's budget fails to provide a substantial increase in funding for schools to carry out their responsibilities under the law."

UPDATE 4: Mike Petrilli (Fordham): "Though it's not the fundamental rethinking of No Child Left Behind that we would have preferred, the president's reauthorization proposal represents a pretty decent repair attempt. It's 50% "stay the course," 30% "tweak and tuck," and 20% "bold new ideas." (Mr. Fix-It)

UPDATE 5: Quick & The Ed (again): "Note to NBC: This woman is NOT Margaret Spellings." (Will the real Margaret Spellings please stand up?)

UPDATE 6: Reality CheckED: "There's been a lot of talk about a backlash to testing, but to the extent that's happening, it seems to be happening among teachers...More than half of parents, about 54%, feel the amount of testing is "about right." (NCLB Gets A Nod)

Eduwonk: "The fact that President Bush’s State of the Union clearly said he wanted No Child reauthorized is significant, as is the placement of education at the top of the speech. But beyond that, not a whole lot in Tuesday night's speech." (All Hat, Hidden Cattle)

The Quick And The Ed: "Am I the only person who found it odd and somewhat unseemly that the President of the United States used a portion of his State of the Union Address to essentially advertise a line of baby toys?" (Bush Hearts Baby Einstein)

For more great blog writing -- that's not about the SOTU speech -- check out my little roundup of some recent favorites here: Great Blog Writing. There's some really good stuff in there.

January 23, 2007

Live-Blogging The State Of The Union (Sort Of)

Jan2307bush_rdax_320x240I should be doing my laundry or feeding my new cat, but instead I'm here, live-blogging the State Of The Union for any glimpses of education news. This is not so easy to do without a drink - where's the Jameson when I really need it? Start at the bottom if you want to read in chronological order. But it's really all over after the first 10 minutes of the speech.

Continue reading "Live-Blogging The State Of The Union (Sort Of)" »

January 22, 2007

State Of The Union Preview: Reauthorize NCLB

Don't expect much from the President about education in the upcoming State Of The Union besides the call to reauthorize NCLB, based on this mention in a White House press briefing last week: " I think that the issues that the President has chosen to talk about in the State of the Union are ones that we all agree on the ultimate goal -- maybe not on every single detail -- but we have different paths of getting there. And I think that he believes that there are ways that we can work together -- on energy reform, there's a lot of common ground there. On education reform, No Child Left Behind is beginning to show some results. And so as that gets reauthorized this year, under the leadership of Secretary Spellings and Senator Ted Kennedy, I think that a lot can get done there."

This is a far cry from last year, when SOTU-watchers were all aflutter about the President's STEM proposal, which like most things mentioned in these speeches went nowhere: $9B Proposed for Science Education.

January 17, 2007

Exclusive: Security Checks For Ed Researchers


It's like a bad episode of "Alias." Mild-mannered researchers working with the USDE are being asked (for the first time, apparently) to fill out investigative reports on themselves and submit to what seems like a security clearance in order to continue their work with the USDE.

"We all have to fill out security questionnaires and get background investigations (and credit checks)," writes one such researcher. "It's very invasive and I can't see the purpose of it other than to get as many people as possible into their homeland security database. Basically if you don't fill it out you can't work on ED projects."

Continue reading "Exclusive: Security Checks For Ed Researchers" »

January 11, 2007

What You Missed From Last Night's Speech

Here's the speech that we wish the President had given last night -- not about sending more troops to Iraq but rather about more gold stars for our nation's schools. Via The Onion.

Bush Earmarks 1.5B Gold Stars For Education
"Vowing to give the nation's public schools "a much-needed boost," President Bush announced Monday that his 2003 budget proposal would allocate 1.5 billion gold-star stickers for education."

Caption reads: "Bush holds up a Dayton, OH, fourth-grader's gold-star-adorned book report on Ferdinand Magellan."

Alexander Russo

Alexander Russo
E-mail me

    Contributors:
  • Fritz Edelstein
  • Regina Matthews
  • Cassie Walker
The opinions expressed in This Week in Education are strictly those of the author and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.
Advertisement
My site was nominated for Best Education Blog!
Powered by
Movable Type 3.34
<

EW Archive