Eduholic

“I can stop talking about teaching whenever I want to,” claims educator-writer Emmet Rosenfeld, who spends much of his time—you guessed it—thinking and talking about teaching. A former English teacher at the renowned Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology in Alexandria, Va., Rosenfeld has recently transitioned to a position as English teacher and Dean of Students at the Congressional Schools of Virginia in Falls Church, Va. Until he comes to terms with his Education Problem, enjoy this wide-ranging blog on teaching and learning in his classroom and beyond.

Main | July 2007 »

June 30, 2007

A Boat with Legs

Readers of “Certifiable?”, last year’s blog chronicling my try for National Board Certification, will remember the dugout canoe my 10th grade Humanities students made along with the help of the Alexandria Seaport Foundation. Highlights included learning about primitive technology from a man clad in buckskins, building 3D models of Western- and Native American-authored novels to compare the authors’ worldviews, and camping out at historic Mount Vernon for an overnight burn-and-scrape party.

“Wind, Water & Stone” was the official title of the project, funded by a grant from a couple TJ grads who hit it big a few years back with a best-selling thriller called the Rule of Four (think DaVinci Code, set at Princeton). I and my co-grant writer, aptly-named force of nature disguised as an English teacher Milde Waterfall, proposed to give a hundred humanities students “a boat’s-eye view of culture, history and technology.” With our partners, history teachers Jen Bain and Carolyn Gecan, we guided the canoe project through our year.

Around each bend was a surprise, whether rough water that forced us to paddle together or an unexpected vista that made us catch our collective breath. A high point for me was the May launch from the banks of Mount Vernon. We christened the S.S. TJHSST (science and tech nerds love acronyms) by smashing a graphing calculator on the bow, then held our breath as the heavy craft slid down a soaped ramp into the water. The boat floated. Standing thigh deep in a river that runs through my life, pushing three kids at a time out into the current for a short ride, pretty much made my year.

And while the school year itself is over, the voyage goes on. The latest stretch is in progress as we speak: the log canoe is on display on the National Mall as part of the 31st annual Smithsonian Folklife Festival. Washington knows summer is here each year when white tents sprout on the greensward in front of the Smithsonian castle. The tents this year house exhibits, food and music from The Mekong Delta, Northern Ireland, and The Roots of Virginia.

Our boat sits in a yard next to a display of African-American oysterers, freedmen who have tended beds in the waters near Suffolk, Virginia for 7 generations. Across the way is a cooper fashioning barrels in the heat, beside a Williamsburg carpenter making a sailor’s chest from fresh yellow pine. The pinging of a mason’s mallet on cathedral stone makes its way over from Ireland.

Beside us, appropriately, is a recreation of John Smith’s shallop, a smallish sailing ship he built especially for exploring the Chesapeake Bay. It was sent over in two halves in the hulls of larger vessels, and assembled at Jamestown from where he made two voyages up and down the various rivers, including our own Potomac, that extend like fingers from the palm of the Bay itself. Now, a crew of ruddy-faced and slightly hirsute interpreters are on a 121-day voyage themselves, roughly retracing Smith’s route while stopping at festivals like this one along the way.

Our proximity to Smith’s boat let me see our own log canoe in a new light. On his travels into ever shallower waters, Smith and his men would no doubt have encountered Natives who paddled up in canoes similar to ours, offering their services as guides or sometimes attacking. One drawing in the Smith tent shows his men smashing log canoes of Nansemond raiders. The caption says the Indians quickly decided to pay protection in lieu of losing more of the labor-intensive boats.

That labor itself was also something for which I gained a new appreciation thanks to the serendipity of the Festival. Over in the Mekong Delta, a contingent of more than a dozen wiry men in traditional garb (black embroidered vests and matching chaps) happened to be making a dugout canoe, from a Tulip poplar log like ours, but with different methods. The Native American technology we used involved chipping the bark with stone adzes and then burning and scraping out the heart wood (we employed nontraditional tools like chainsaws at certain points to speed the process). The Mekong builders forego fire or two-stroke engine: at any hour of the two-week build, one can see three or four men at a time wielding Vietnamese axes-- the handles are bow-shaped, not straight-- sending up a spray of chips as they fashion their own log boat.

We had our own labor force back at our canoe. The oyster shells left strewn inside for effect turned out to be a magnet for children who enjoyed the hands on activity of scraping away at the still charred inner walls. While they did, students and I manning the display chatted with their parents, or whoever else strolled along to glance at our boat and the laminated posters we’d made in lieu of a final exam. Being a docent made me realize how much I had learned along the way:

“It’s a Tulip poplar from Warrenton, Virginia, born in 1891... the design is ‘post-contact’ in that a traditional ‘hog-trough’ has this Western-style pointed prow... we controlled the fire by packing river mud on the parts we didn’t want to burn... Walter Plecker was a state registrar in Virginia in the 1920s who almost single-handedly eradicated Native people from the census rolls by aggressively enforcing the ‘one-drop’ rule ...yes, TJ is a Governor’s magnet school, these high tech kids built a low tech boat...”.

One special visitor was a Native American man with silver hair pulled back in a pony tail and a salt-soaked accent from southern Virginia that I couldn’t quite place. He was interested in our project, but surprised me when I mentioned Walter Plecker. “I wish I’d driven the car that hit him,” the man said. That’s how Plecker died, he told me, sometime in the 40s, and went on to explain how his own brothers had been denied an education past the seventh grade in Virginia due to the application of Jim Crow rules to Indians.

Turns out, I was talking to Mr. Ben Adams, part of a recent delegation that made a splash before the official start of the 400th by traveling across the big pond to Kent, England. Their honorary visit focused international attention on the upcoming observances and the current day status of Virginia's Indians, creating positive spin for Native people in their continuing efforts to achieve full recognition.

“Funny thing is,” Adams added, “in the end, Plecker helped us. He forced us to know who we are. And we’re stronger today because of it.”

“By the way... what are you going to do with it?”

That was a question we’d been wrestling with. We’d talked about mounting the boat in the school courtyard, even contacted the PTA about turning it into a planter. It didn’t feel right, but what do you do with a 300-pound log canoe?

“Why don’t you give it to me?” Adams proposed. He teaches Indian kids about their culture, and said they would use the boat in the water on a regular basis. “Come on down next fall,” he went on. “You can present it and we’ll do some kind of ceremony.” He left me with his card, and the feeling that once again, this journey had surprised me.

June 23, 2007

Call to Fingers

a) Who knew?
b) Gosh.
c) I’m not worthy.
d) What can we do with it?

In the spirit of Eduholic, here in multiple choice format are the waves of what I felt after reading the dozens of comments responding to last week’s inaugural post. (Read to the end for the best answer.) I never realized there were so many of us out there, waiting for a name.

I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that other educators connect with a good metaphor when they see one. Comparison is one of the most powerful tools I know for explaining things in a way people can understand.

And making ourselves understood, after all, is what defines us. The act implies a partner: an understander-- a student-- to complete us. Those who park themselves in front of a room and just talk, or otherwise go through the motions, but don’t care whether students are getting it-- they aren’t teaching. (And, yes, I admit there are times when I fall into this category. But I don’t live there. I struggle to Teach, and on my best days get it right.)

This two-way act is implicit in National Board’s drumbeat for “student achievement,” which to me rescues the process from its own overgrown rule book. It’s also firmly at the heart of “student-centered” teaching in the best constructivist sense, embodied in the “how do I know what I think until I write it” ethos of my own favorite professional development model, the National Writing Project.

If being understood, then, is truly at the heart of what we do, Eduholics everywhere have got to face up to an uncomfortable truth: Most of the world doesn’t. Parents, politicians, and the public don’t get it. In general, they have no clue what we do or how we do it, nor can they fathom the challenges we face and the heights to which we soar on a near daily basis.

You name it, they don’t see it. Instead, they see numbers. Test scores, mostly, and occasionally statistics. Education reporters offer up snapshots, it’s true, trying their best to put a face on the issue. But even the best of them are visitors, not partners in the messy magic practice we engage in every day.

And don’t get me started on policy wonks in cubicles. Again, I won’t dispute that they provide a certain type of insight. Sometimes, they’re even right. For example, here’s a study by scholars from a think tank called the Urban Institute that argues in favor of the efficacy of Board Certified teachers. I think. It lays out an “analytic approach” that “[begins] by estimating a basic educational production function of the following form...”. (For a special treat, go to page 7 of the pdf and see the actual equation, complete with Greek letters and subscripts, that boils down what happens in a classroom full of pheromone-drenched teenagers under the careful guidance of a master teacher.)

Point being (and here I speak to letter “d” from the answer choices), it’s time for Eduholics everywhere to tell their tales from the classroom in ways the world can understand. We need to make our voices heard beyond the walls if we want to play a meaningful role in improving schools and teacher pay. That’s the lesson for today. And the correct answer to the pop quiz? e), of course: All of the above.


June 17, 2007

2:27 A.M.


My name is Emmet and I’m an eduholic.

The last time I woke up in the middle of the night to write about education , I was in the throes of scaling Mount Nbpts. Now I’m out of thin air, it’s the weekend before the last day of the school year... and I’m at it again.

I thought once the portfolio was signed, sealed and delivered these middle of the night sessions would be over, but I can see now that I was deceiving myself. If it’s not National Board that’s got me spinning, it’s that kid from second period, or ideas for an upcoming lesson. Or rehearsing the first few lines of a blog post. Can you hear a cast iron skillet clanging violently against my keyboard? That's my brain on education.

Fortunately, I’m not alone. Seems there are a lot of people out there just like me. The kind folks at Teacher online have agreed to let me talk it out here, in this new blog. Even better, anybody who wants to can come on in and join the conversation. Half the fun last time was hearing what teachers from around the country had to say. A giant teacher’s lounge, sort of, except without the nattering nabobs.

So, from here on in I’ll be writing each week about my teaching life, and I invite you to share yours. Let’s face it, even with all those students, it gets awful lonely in front of the classroom sometimes. Especially if you keep your door shut, which can be a temptation in a job like ours.

Now, I know I’m launching this at a weird time. After all, it’s summer, and a lot of us are preparing to forget about school for a week or ten. Blurry screen like heat rays off the pavement, dissolve to man before the ocean, digging toes into the sand, reaching for a sweating Corona beside his beach chair...

Must. Come. Back. It’s the little things I can’t let go of (mortgage, food). So, rather than quit cold turkey, I’m downshifting. This summer, instead of a full-time day gig and night school, my normal load, I plan on only teaching a couple college courses.

Besides offering a change of pace from the work I do with rocket scientists-in-training during the regular school year at a high tech magnet school, Voices from the Classroom and good old freshman comp at the community college will give me something to write about.

So stay tuned to hear about how teacher-researchers and other educators develop professional writing for publication. Lend an ear while I coax adult learners to write research papers. And jump in any time with nuggets of wisdom, questions, or feedback.

Because, let’s face it: if you weren’t into that sort of stuff, you wouldn’t be here. Reading this blog, or in this job. And that’s okay. The first step, after all, is admitting you have a problem.

Emmet Rosenfeld

Emmet Rosenfeld.

Get RSS

Advertisement

Categories

Powered by
Movable Type 3.34

TM Archive