« Dallas Teachers Brace for Pink Slips | Main | Math Problems »

When Pedagogy and Politics Collide

| 4 Comments

Teachers at various points across the country have come under fire recently for showing their support for Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama. The Virginia Education Association sent out an e-mail encouraging its members to wear “Obama blue” last week, prompting outrage among state Republicans about political influence in schools. In New York City, meanwhile, the Department of Education has clamped down on a United Federation of Teachers plan to have teachers wear pro-Obama buttons in their classrooms. And a group of teachers at Soquel High School in Santa Cruz, CA chose to wear “Educators for Obama” buttons in school. These events have re-raised issues of a teacher’s rights to free speech and the place of politics in the classroom.

John Hadley, a pro-McCain parent whose daughter attends Soquel, was angered by the button-wearing teachers, saying, "[They] lose their free-speech rights when they go into a classroom. They are allowed to stick to the curriculum, not political views.”

According to the San Jose Mercury News, under California law, limits on teachers political activities at school are set by districts. In general, legal decisions in the state the have held that teaches are permitted to wear political buttons to school but not during class time. At this point, the Soquel teachers have decided not to wear theirs.

In defense of their in-school Obama support, several New York City teachers cited a 1969 U.S. Supreme Court ruling. The ruling, which focused on political protest in school, stated that as long as the actions weren’t “disruptive and did not impinge upon the rights of others … [the activity was] within the protection of the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth.”

The NY DOE responded to the button handouts by saying, "Schools are not a place for politics and not a place for staff to wear political buttons … We don't want a school or school staff advocating for any political position or candidate to students and we don't want students feeling intimidated because they might hold a different belief or support a different candidate than their teachers.”


Update 10/13/08: Teachers Union Sues Over Political Button Ban

4 Comments

I am not an Obama supporter because I think his positions tend toward a socialist state that would not be good for us. I say that just so you know that I am not speaking in opposition to him, just to his ideas. I think it would be wise for teachers to keep their opinions to themselves; after all, they are not influencing voters :) I think they might do well to organize a point-by-point comparison between the two candidates ... it would be a great English or social studies assignment.

The main reason for this is suggested in the last paragraph. Students might feel limited in THEIR freedom of speech when they know their teacher's strongly held position. Give them the information; let them make up their minds.

It should be considered unprofessional conduct to advocate a political position in the classroom. You can't use your email for that purpose, or the school property. There is no freedom of speech on the job, and you alienate and disenfranchise students who disagree with you. Its THEIR classroom, not yours. Period.

Well I work in a school where one team of teachers has chosen to only hang McCain / Palin posters.
This is not right and I feel tht all candidates should be represented if there will be any posters. This includes Green candidates and Indepoendents

I think Mary has a good point. Instead of having NO opinion, why not share ALL opinions with students ... and make sure they know that all opinions have value and should be explored. There are many great projects you can do around election time, and it will be more than a little difficult not to voice and opinion ... but teaching our students what an OPINION is seems like an important part of what we do.

And I do not think it's the student's classroom; I think it's OUR classroom.

Comments are now closed for this post.

Advertisement

Recent Comments

  • tim: I think Mary has a good point. Instead of having read more
  • Mary: Well I work in a school where one team of read more
  • Ebasco: It should be considered unprofessional conduct to advocate a political read more
  • tim: I am not an Obama supporter because I think his read more

Archives

Categories

Technorati

Technorati search

» Blogs that link here