« Teach For America CEO Transitions Into Board Role | Main | Teacher Gets Valentine's Card 67 Years Straight »

Teacher Touts Chucking Classroom Rules, Consequences

In this ASCD SmartBlog post, a 20-year veteran teacher describes how he went from a "classic rules-and-consequences" management style to a "no-rules, no-consequences" approach.

Mark Barnes writes that for many years, he had a list of punishments for particular infractions. Chewing gum = detention. Head on the desk = stand up for the rest of class. He was proud of his reputation as a strict disciplinarian, he writes. But eventually, he realized it wasn't effective:

What I failed to comprehend in my "I'm-the-meanest-teacher-in-the-school" approach was that I had created a classroom based on control, and I was alienating my students, and my creation was alienating my students. They may have, on occasion, acquiesced to my list of demands, but most of the time their compliance came at the price of learning. After all, what child would embrace education in this kind of militant classroom?

Barnes made some drastic changes, both to his methods and his mindset. Most importantly, he changed his focus from control to student results. He explains:

A no-rules, no-consequences learning community, based on cooperation and filled with exciting activities and projects engages students and eliminates boredom. When students are working collaboratively, using technology, leaving their seats and, yes, even chewing gum, they are more likely to complete activities and projects and less likely to be disruptive. Rules and consequences, in this bustling, student-centered classroom, are easily replaced with discussions of mutual respect, individual conferences with those who take longer to embrace the controlled chaos that governs the room and rapport-building rather than strictness.

The post is short on specifics but, well, Barnes is publishing a book that is sure to include them. What's your initial reaction? Is this sort of adjustment necessary or idealistic? Is it risky to encourage teachers to let go of the reins?

Notice: We recently upgraded our comments. (Learn more here.) If you are logged in as a subscriber or registered user and already have a Display Name on edweek.org, you can post comments. If you do not already have a Display Name, please create one here.
Ground Rules for Posting
We encourage lively debate, but please be respectful of others. Profanity and personal attacks are prohibited. By commenting, you are agreeing to abide by our user agreement.
All comments are public.

Follow This Blog


Most Viewed On Teacher



Recent Comments